Op-Ed: The Mayor’s Budget Wouldn’t Survive My Mom’s Audit

[Op-Ed by Dan Murphy, Snoqualmie Council Member and resident. Views expressed are those of the author, not Living Snoqualmie. You may submit letters to [email protected].]

I was raised by a single mom, a CPA who became the first female partner at her accounting firm in New Jersey. She taught me three lessons about money: Don’t spend what you don’t have, when you’re already in a hole, stop digging, and where your money goes shows what you care about.

I thought of her when I read the Mayor’s proposed budget. It wouldn’t survive her audit.

If you tossed away the dramatically titled flyer that came with your utility bill, “The Choice Before Snoqualmie,” or skipped one of the recent community meetings, you didn’t miss anything particularly informative or helpful.

The flyers and the presentations paint a grim picture of inflation’s toll on Snoqualmie. “Snoqualmie is losing ground,” one mailer warns, as “declining resident ratings” pile up and park repairs “remain unfinished.” They insist there’s only one way out of this awful nightmare. And that way is the Mayor’s budget, which expands city headcount and is paid for with a large 10-year property tax levy that neither the City Council nor residents have approved. The only alternative, according to the Mayor, is deep cuts to police, fire, parks and other essential services.

It’s like walking onto the used car lot where the dealer tells you there are only two choices: the model you can’t quite afford, or the clunker with the bumper falling off. He conveniently forgets to mention the sensible, affordable option on the other side of the lot.

Facing a projected budget gap of about $1.5 million, the Mayor proposes adding 10.5 permanent positions. The budget pays for those new commitments by spending nearly all of the City’s General Fund balance to get through 2027, then assumes a substantial property-tax increase in 2028 will balance the books—an increase the City Council already rejected 6–1 in August.

The Mayor’s budget recklessly uses one-time savings to pay for permanent expenses, then counts on future revenue that hasn’t been approved to sustain those expenses going forward. Salaries, benefits and other recurring costs don’t go away when the savings run out. And by building the budget around a future levy lid lift, the Mayor is effectively spending money before voters have agreed to provide it. That puts residents in an unfair position: By the time they’re asked to approve a tax increase, the city will have already committed itself to the additional spending. If voters say no, the city faces a much bigger problem than the one it has today. The Mayor’s flyer calls this “The Choice Before Snoqualmie.” But what choice will residents really have once he’s spent our savings and comes asking for a bailout?

I was one of those six votes opposing the levy lid lift this year. Here’s why: Our local economy has cooled. Many Snoqualmie households depend on a tech industry that has shed jobs, and everyone is paying more for groceries and gas. City utility rates are scheduled to rise every year through 2030, and if Puget Sound Energy gets its way, power bills are next. Our city property tax rate is already higher than our neighbors’ in Issaquah, North Bend and Sammamish. This isn’t about austerity; it’s about remembering that every dollar the city spends comes out of a family’s budget, and family budgets are tighter now than they’ve been in years.

Now let’s take a look at where this money goes. Most of the new hiring is in finance and legal, plus a full-time executive assistant to handle the Mayor’s correspondence, calendar, and travel, among other duties. What the budget doesn’t include is a cent of dedicated funding for our legal fight against the BlackRock Jupiter Power battery farm proposed next to our city. This year we needed a $500,000 budget amendment for BESS legal and consultant costs, but the Mayor’s budget sets aside nothing for 2027 or 2028. Hundreds of residents packed City Council chambers, organized and marched over this issue, and leaving it out of the budget is a staggering omission.

Snoqualmie, like many cities across the state, has real financial obstacles ahead. The state’s 1% cap on how much the city’s property tax collections can grow each year doesn’t come close to keeping up with inflation, and at some point in the near future the city will have to ask voters for a levy lid lift. To be clear, I think that’s a matter of when, not if. But we need to be a lot smarter about the ask and make sure residents see real, tangible value in paying more. And we need to make it transparently, weighing real options with residents instead of talking at them with a threat-laden sales pitch.

There is a better option that I hope my fellow Councilmembers can consider. It starts with protecting our hardworking professional staff. This budget gap can be closed without a single layoff, and I hope that the Mayor affirms that. Second, we shouldn’t add permanent positions until we can name the recurring revenue that pays for them. If a job matters enough to add, it matters enough to fund sustainably. Third, where we draw on savings, use them as a bridge to hold current essential services steady—police, fire, parks—not to prematurely grow headcount. This buys us time to bring voters a better-designed, more sensible levy with clearer benefits. Finally, take a hard look at the millions set aside for future construction, including the community center expansion. Not all of that money can legally be moved, but the Legislature has given cities more flexibility to use some of it for ongoing maintenance. We should know how far it stretches, and what we would have to defer, before anyone tells you a tax increase is the only answer.

The City Council holds a public hearing on the budget November 23. Please come and give public comment, or if you can’t make it, email us at [email protected].

My mom never ran a city. But she spent a career reading balance sheets, and she knew the money you hope for isn’t money you have. The real choice before Snoqualmie isn’t a tax increase or layoffs. It’s whether we fund what matters most with money we actually have. That’s a budget that would pass her audit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Living Snoqualmie